Postmillennialism and Missions

On June 23rd 1833, Princeton Seminary graduate James Eckard was about to set sail for Ceylon (Sri Lanka). He took with him a letter written by ten year old Archibald Alexander Hodge and his sister Mary Elizabeth. The letter was addressed to the “heathen.” It said:

Dear heathen,

The Lord Jesus Christ has promised that the time shall come when all the ends of the earth shall be his kingdom. And God is not a man that he should lie nor the son of man that he should repent.

And if this was promised by a Being who cannot lie, why do you not help it to come sooner by reading the Bible, and attending to the words of your teachers, and loving God, and, renouncing your idols, and taking Christianity into your temples?

And soon there will be not a Nation, no, not a space of ground a large as a footstep, that will want a missionary. 

My sister and myself, by small self-denials, procured two dollars which are enclosed in this letter to buy Bibles and tracts to teach you.

Archibald Alexander Hodge and Mary Elizabeth Hodge,

Friends of the Heathen

For postmillennialists, missions has always been about building and transforming institutions just as much as saving individual souls. Discipling a nation requires more than just soul-winning, it requires culture building.

A. A. Hodge of Princeton, who was himself a missionary in India in his early years, correctly saw the major change in missionary strategy which the new (in his day) premillennial prophetic viewpoint had brought about, compared to what earlier postmillennial missionaries had done:

“[Premillennial] missionaries have a style of their own. Their theory affects their work in the way of making them seek exclusively, or chiefly, the conversion of individual souls. The true and efficient missionary method is, to aim directly, indeed, at soul winning, but at the same time to plant Christian institutions in heathen lands, which will, in time, develop according to the genius of the nationalities. English missionaries can never hope to convert the world directly by [individual] units.” (from Iain Murray, The Puritan Hope, p. 204f)

The traditional, Reformed, postmillennial understanding of the Great Commission understood that discipling nations had both individual and institutional aspects. They not only preached the gospel, they established Christian institutions to bring about the transformation of culture.

A. A. Hodge, summarizing the eschatology of old Princeton:

“This kingdom is to endure for ever, gradually to embrace all the  inhabitants of the earth, and finally the entire moral government of God  in heaven and on earth. The little stone which breaks the image will  become a great mountain and fill the whole earth (Dan. 2:35). This  gospel of the kingdom is to be preached to all nations. Then all the  kingdoms of this world shall become the kingdoms of our Lord and of his  Christ, and he shall reign for ever and ever. And in the dispensation of  the fullness of times all things, both which are in heaven and which  are on earth, are to be gathered together in one in Christ; who is set  at the right hand of God in heavenly places, far above all principality  and power and might and dominion, and every name that is named, not only  in this world, but also in that which is to come; and all things are  put under his feet, He only being excepted that did put all things under  him (Eph. 1:10, 20, 21; 1 Cor. 15:27). 

III. The process by  which this kingdom grows through its successive stages toward its  ultimate completion can of course be very inadequately understood by us.  It implies the ceaseless operation of the mighty power of God working  through all the forces and laws of nature and culminating in the  supernatural manifestations of grace and of miracle. The Holy Ghost is  everywhere present, and he works directly alike in the ways we  distinguish as natural and as supernatural—alike through appointed  instruments and agencies, and immediately by his direct personal power.  The special agency for the building up of this kingdom is the organized  Christian Church with its regular ministry, providing for the preaching  of the gospel and the administration of the sacraments. The special work  of the Holy Ghost in building up this kingdom is performed in the  regeneration and sanctification of individuals through the ministry of  the Church. But beyond this the omnipresent Holy Ghost works to the same  end, directly and indirectly, in every sphere of nature and of human  life, causing all the historic movements of peoples and nations, of  civilization and of science, of political and ecclesiastical societies,  to broaden and deepen the foundations and to advance the growth and  perfection of his kingdom. Thus this kingdom from the beginning and in  the whole circle of human history has been always coming. Its coming has  been marked by great epochs, when new revelations and new  communications of divine power have been imported from without into the  current of human history. The chiefest of these have been the giving of  the law, the incarnation, crucifixion, resurrection, ascension and  session of the King on the right hand of the Father, and the mission of  the Holy Ghost. Yet the kingdom has been always coming every moment of  all the years that have passed. In all the growing of the seeds and all  the blowing of the winds; in every event, even the least significant,  which has advanced the interests of the human family either in respect  to their bodies or their souls, and thus made their lives better or  worthier; in all the breaking of fetters; in all the bringing in of  light; in the noiseless triumphs of peace; in the dying out of  barbarisms; and in the colonization of great continents with new  populations and free states,—the kingdom is coming. Above all, in the  multiplication of the myriad centres of Christian missions and of the  myriad hosts of Christian workers, each in the spirit of the King  seeking the very lowest and most degraded, everywhere lifting upward  what Satan’s kingdom has borne down,—the kingdom is coming. Its process  is like that of the constructive power of the kingdom of nature, silent  and invisible, yet omnipresent and omnipotent, like the rain and the dew  and the zephyr and the sunlight. The kingdom comes intensively in each  heart like the leaven, which penetrates the whole mass silently yet  irresistibly until all is leavened. It comes extensively like the growth  of the mustard-seed, which from the least beginnings unfolds itself  until it shoots out great branches and shelters the fowls of heaven. In  this World the wheat and the tares, the good and the evil, grow together  to the end. The net gathers in fish good and bad. One field brings  forth thirty, another forty, and another an hundred-fold. In the end the  tares shall be gathered and burned, and the pure wheat gathered without  mixture in the eternal garner of the Lord. In the whole history of its  coming the kingdom of God “cometh not with observation: neither shall  they say, Lo, here! or, Lo, there! for behold, the kingdom of God is  within you.” But its consummation shall be ushered in suddenly and with  overwhelming demonstrations of glory: “For as the lightning, that  lighteneth out of the one part under heaven, shineth unto the other part  under heaven; so shall also the Son of man be in his day.” For the  present the King is absent, gathering together in his grasp the reins of  his empire: we are left to be diligently employed with the doing the  utmost for his cause possible within our respective spheres against his  coming. When he comes he will be revealed as a King of kings, followed  by great retinues of royal princes sitting on thrones and reigning over  cities in his name and through his grace.”